Kinsella On Liberty

KOL502 | Abolish Intellectual Property? Stephan Kinsella on Objectively Speaking: Scarcity, Negative Servitudes, IP, Objectivism, AI Copyright, and Bitcoin Ownership

13 Oct 2026
Philosophy

Description

Kinsella on Liberty Podcast: Episode 502. Cross-posted at PFS Blog. This is my conversation on Liquid Zulu's Twitter Space (@PunishedZulu), recorded Oct. 12, 2026. Topics discussed include why property rights require scarcity, the case against IP as non-consensual negative servitudes, critiques of Locke, Rand, and utilitarian arguments, Objectivism and Atlas Shrugged, AI training and copyright liability, international IP treaties, and whether Bitcoin can be owned. Update: See LiquidZulu vs. Liebowitz debating IP: Debating Michael Liebowitz on Intellectual Property (Oct. 24, 2026) https://www.youtube.com/live/QSYHSWXYIsk?si=_d7b1wxAv51OKDt4 It’s time to announce the topic of our next Objectively Speaking episode! 🎙️ This time, we’ll be discussing Intellectual Property with a very special guest, @NSKinsella. Hosted as always by @PunishedZulu, @eduardoyanez__, and me. 📅 Monday, October 12th ⏰ 4:30 PM Eastern Time Location: Twitter Space/Zulu’s YT stream Hope to see you there! — thisissu (@Eudaimoniang) October 7, 2026 Related KOL454 | Debating Various Issues of Interest to Objectivists and Libertarians on The Rational Egoist (Michael Liebowitz) KOL451 | Debating the Nature of Rights on The Rational Egoist (Michael Liebowitz) Kinsella, Mises and Rand (and Rothbard) The Problem with Intellectual Property. Stephan Kinsella, Papinian Press Occasional Paper, No. 2 (Houston, Texas: Papinian Press, May 15, 2025) [v.1.1]. ISBN Ebook 979-8-9890306-8-2. — Kinsella’s most recent and comprehensive short presentation of the case against patents and copyrights, covering scarcity, negative servitudes, and why IP is incompatible with libertarian property rights. Intellectual Property Rights as Negative Servitudes. Stephan Kinsella, C4SIF Blog (June 2011). — Explains the core argument from the episode that IP grants are non-consensual negative servitudes restricting the use of others’ already-owned scarce resources. The Mountain of IP Legislation. Stephan Kinsella, C4SIF Blog (November 2010). — Documents the extensive and growing body of IP statutes, illustrating the arbitrary, legislated nature of patent and copyright terms discussed in the episode. Against Intellectual Property. N. Stephan Kinsella, Journal of Libertarian Studies 15, no. 2 (Spring 2001): 1–53; later issued as a monograph by the Ludwig von Mises Institute (2008) and Laissez Faire Books (2012). — The classic systematic libertarian case against IP, including critiques of natural-rights and utilitarian justifications. Against Intellectual Property After Twenty Years: Looking Back and Looking Forward. Stephan Kinsella, chapter 15 of Legal Foundations of a Free Society (Houston, Texas: Papinian Press, 2023); also available at C4SIF. — Reflects on the original AIP arguments, updates them, and discusses the shift in libertarian opinion against IP over two decades. Law and Intellectual Property in a Stateless Society. Stephan Kinsella, Libertarian Papers 5, no. 1 (2013): 1–44; updated version appears as chapter 14 of Legal Foundations of a Free Society (Houston, Texas: Papinian Press, 2023). — Comprehensive treatment of why IP cannot exist in a free, private-law order based on self-ownership, homesteading, and contract. The Case Against IP: A Concise Guide. Stephan Kinsella, Mises Daily (September 4, 2009). — Short, accessible overview of the main arguments against IP, including the failure of both deontological and utilitarian defenses. The Overwhelming Empirical Case Against Patent and Copyright. Stephan Kinsella, C4SIF Blog (October 23, 2012); also chapter 31 of The Anti-IP Reader (Papinian Press, 2023). — Collects studies (including Machlup and others) showing no clear evidence that patents or copyrights produce net gains in innovation, relevant to the utilitarian discussion. Intellectual Property and Libertarianism. Stephan Kinsella, Mises Daily (November 17, 2009); earlier version in Liberty 23, no. 11 (December 2009). — Explains the tension between IP and core libertarian principles of property and the non-aggression principle, with discussion of Randian and other creatio

Comments

No comments yet — be the first to write one.