
Why I Take Zero Supplements After 30 Years as a Health Coach: Scope of Practice, Proprietary Blends and Marketing Traps
14 Nov 2026 ยท 13:02
CareersDescription
Episode Summary
Clients ask health coaches about supplements all the time, and many coaches aren't sure how to answer. Erin Power has spent more than 30 years in the industry and tried hundreds of products, yet today she takes none and doesn't recommend any to her clients. In this episode, she explains why.
Erin walks through the research on inaccurate labels, failed quality tests and heavy metal contamination, and shows how terms like "proprietary blend" let companies hide what's really in their products. She also calls out influencer promo codes, buzzword supplements that promise to fix problems the brands invented, and the risks behind thousands of emergency room visits every year.
For coaches, Erin is clear about where the line sits: prescribing or selling supplements is outside a health coach's scope of practice. She shares a client story that shows how a bottle of drops can pull people away from real change, and explains why food, movement, sunlight and sleep are what actually move the dial.
Episode Overview
00:00 Cold Open
00:27 Why Erin Takes Zero Supplements
00:54 83% of Weight Loss Supplements Had Inaccurate Labels
01:12 Why Supplements Are Essentially Unregulated
01:36 Failed Quality Tests and Heavy Metal Contamination
02:13 The Proprietary Blend Trick
03:27 Influencers, Promo Codes and Hidden Commissions
03:59 A Health Coach's Scope of Practice
04:32 23,000 ER Visits a Year From Supplements
05:32 30 Years of Trying Supplements: Erin's Experience
06:18 The Client Who Chose Soursop Drops
06:58 Supplements With Credible Science Behind Them
07:47 Why Erin Still Doesn't Take Any
08:24 Buzzword Supplements: Glow, Lean, Balance
09:40 The Truth About Plant Peptides
10:09 Supplements That Invent Their Own Problems
10:41 When Supplements Do Make Sense
11:08 The Optimize-Everything Market
11:44 The Industry's Best Product Is a Feeling
12:27 One Habit to Lock In for 30 Days
Key Themes and Takeaways
Labels Can't Be Trusted
A 2024 study of 30 weight loss supplements found 83% had inaccurate labels, and independent lab testing has found more than one in four supplements failing quality checks.
Proprietary Blends Hide the Recipe
Companies must list the ingredients in a blend but not how much of each they used. Erin recommends avoiding any product that hides individual doses.
Supplements Sit Outside the Coach's Scope
Health coaches don't prescribe or sell supplements. Erin also warns against undisclosed promo codes and commissions, which compromise a coach's credibility.
Not Risk Free
Supplements are linked to around 23,000 emergency room visits a year in the US, most commonly from weight loss pills, energy products and multivitamins.
Some Supplements Have a Place
Creatine, omega-3s, magnesium, and vitamin D with K2 have credible science behind them, and diagnosed deficiencies, pregnancy, certain surgeries and restrictive diets are legitimate reasons to supplement.
The Real Treatment Is the Basics
The industry's best product is the feeling that you're doing something. Erin challenges listeners to lock in one basic habit for 30 days instead.
Research Mentioned
- 2024 analysis of 30 weight loss supplements (83% with inaccurate labels, 23% with hidden ingredients)
- ConsumerLab report, 2023 (more than one in four supplements failed quality testing)
- Operation Supplement Safety, U.S. Department of Defense, on proprietary blend labeling
- New England Journal of Medicine study on emergency room visits linked to dietary supplements, with a Harvard Medical School analysis
- Study on ingredient levels in Nutrafol exceeding recommended daily values
This episode is for educatio
Comments
No comments yet โ be the first to write one.