Oral Arguments, with Context

Russell v. Zysman, et al. — 9th Cir. (Nov 18, 2026)

19 ноя 2026 · 38:36
Государство

Описание

The Ninth Circuit hears a dispute over a prison blanket, an alleged injury, and whether correctional officers can be sued for their response. Nevada prisoner Russell says he covered his cell window while using the toilet. According to his complaint, officers reached through the food slot and grabbed the covering as he was taking it down. He says they pulled harder during the struggle, causing him to fall and injuring his hands and an already injured knee. He also alleges this was retaliation for filing grievances against prison officers. The officers say they needed to see inside the cell for security and that Russell resisted removal of the covering. The district court refused to dismiss his excessive-force and retaliation claims on qualified-immunity grounds. The officers now appeal, arguing that prior cases did not clearly establish that their conduct was unconstitutional in these circumstances. Their lawyer will argue that the complaint describes a legitimate effort to restore visibility, not a clearly unlawful use of force. Russell’s lawyer will argue that a legitimate security goal does not excuse unnecessary force or punishment for filing grievances. Listen for how the judges read a complaint written without a lawyer: which facts and reasonable inferences must be accepted now, and which questions should wait for evidence. This is an early-stage immunity appeal, not a trial deciding whose account is true. Russell v. Zysman, et al. (No. 25-5079) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 18, 2026. Sources: Official Ninth Circuit oral argument: https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/media/2026/11/18/25-5079.mp3 Official recording listing: https://www.ca9.uscourts.gov/cases/streams-videos/archive?case=25-5079&hearingDate=2026-11-18 District court order denying dismissal (Doc35): https://cases.justia.com/federal/district-courts/nevada/nvdce/3%3A2023cv00549/165341/35/0.pdf

Комментарии

Комментариев пока нет — напишите первый.