TOMB OF HORRORS Pt 1 (Remastered) - Welcome to the meat grinder

In this episode, the RPGBOT.Podcast crew bravely (and foolishly) opens the first rusted gate into Tomb of Horrors, one of the deadliest and most legendary modules in tabletop RPG history. Originally written by Gary Gygax to humble overconfident players and their min-maxed murderhobos, the Tomb has become a rite of passage for generations of adventurers who thought they were smart. They weren’t.

The hosts dive into the legacy, design philosophy, and gameplay experience of Tomb of Horrors, from its origins in early tournament play to the sadistic joy it brings DMs and the crushing despair it brings players. They analyze why this deathtrap dungeon still matters today, how to survive it (hint: you won’t), and what modern lessons GMs can learn from its brutal design.

Spoiler alert: There are puzzles. There are traps. There is no mercy.

The Origins of the Tomb

• Written by Gary Gygax in 1975 for tournament play at Origins I.
• Designed specifically to kill off characters run by smug powergamers.
• Later published in 1978 as S1: Tomb of Horrors, and updated across editions including 3E, 4E, 5E (Tales from the Yawning Portal), and even in Ready Player One.

The Philosophy of Pain

• Tomb of Horrors isn't about combat—it's about punishing overconfidence.
• Encourages player skill over character sheet. You can’t punch your way through this dungeon.
• A brutal mix of riddles, false doors, lethal traps, and one very smug demilich.

Theater of Brutality

• Gygax’s use of boxed text and riddles set a template for narrative traps.
• The party isn’t just punished physically, but psychologically. “Congratulations, you poked the wrong wall and died instantly.”
• Puzzle Madness
• The module requires deep logic puzzles and metagame thinking.
• Hosts discuss how this creates a blend of escape room and psychological horror more than traditional dungeon crawling.

Modern Takeaways

• How GMs can use elements of the Tomb to design clever traps and tests without just steamrolling players.
• Emphasizing consequence and caution in modern storytelling.
• How to prep your players for a game that isn't fair—and was never meant to be.