4 Nov 2026 05:00
The Great Reliability Crash of 2016: Why Finding a Reliable Used Car Has Become So Damn Complicated
Why is it so difficult to find a reliable used SUV for $20,000? Even brands with stellar reputations, like Toyota and Honda, have had their share of expensive engine and transmission problems. And if you're shopping for a vehicle built between 2015 and 2020, you might be walking into a mechanical minefield.
In this episode of The Straight Shift, The Car Chick explores how tightening fuel economy standards, rapidly changing engine and transmission technology, and increasingly complicated electronics created a perfect storm of reliability problems. From Toyota Highlander transmissions and Subaru oil consumption to Nissan CVTs and Hyundai's dual-clutch headaches, we look at what went wrong, why it matters, and what manufacturers have done to address these issues.
Most importantly, you'll learn why buying a used car based solely on the manufacturer's reputation is a lousy strategy, how to research known problems before you buy, and why sometimes finding a dependable vehicle means choosing which potential problems you're willing to live with.
And looking ahead, will today's increasingly technology-heavy vehicles make affordable, reliable used cars even harder to find ten years from now?
In This Episode
- Why $20,000 doesn't necessarily buy a trouble-free used SUV anymore.
- How federal CAFE fuel economy standards influenced engine and transmission development.
- Why some 2015–2020 vehicles developed expensive reliability problems.
- Real-world examples from Toyota, Honda, Subaru, Nissan, and Hyundai.
- How better fuel economy can come with higher ownership and repair costs.
- How to investigate known problems, warranty extensions, and documented repairs.
- Why every used-car buyer needs to learn to "pick your poison."
- What the future might hold for affordable used cars as technology continues to evolve.
Resources & Links
You can view a full list of resources and episode transcripts here. Connect with LeeAnn:
Work with LeeAnn:
Copyright ©2024 Women’s Automotive Solutions Inc., dba The Car Chick. All rights reserved.
