Home Run Derby vs. Dunk Contest: Paulie Ranks Them All

Paul Rosenberg takes over for Cinco de Luncho with his ranking of the best skills competitions across major sports. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber weigh in as the NBA dunk contest, three point contest, NHL hardest shot, and fastest skater events all battle for a spot near the top. The Home Run Derby claims first place thanks to its unforgettable moments and pure power, but the crew makes a strong case for hockey’s accuracy challenge. They also debate why star participation matters and which competitions deliver the best mix of skill, speed, and entertainment.